About AAQR

Aims and Scope

Articles online
For contributors
Call for Papers
Guideline for the
Special Issue Proposal


Contact Us
Search for  in   Search  Advanced search  


Volume 15, No. 2, April 2015, Pages 694-701 PDF(253 KB)  
doi: 10.4209/aaqr.2014.04.0074   

Analyzing the Relationship between CO2 Emission and Economic Efficiency by a Relaxed Two-Stage DEA Model

Je-Liang Liou1, Ching-Ren Chiu2, Fung-Mey Huang3, Wan-Yu Liu4

1 Chung-Hua Institution for Economic Research, Taipei 106, Taiwan
2 Institute of Service Management, National Penghu University of Science and Technology, Penghu 880, Taiwan
3 Department of Agricultural Economics, National Taiwan University, Taipei 106, Taiwan
4 Department of Tourism Information, Aletheia University, New Taipei City 251, Taiwan


  • A novel two-stage DEA model for energy-related efficiency with undesirable outputs.
  • Our model relaxes constraints between two stages to allow more policy implications.
  • Energy use and economic efficiencies of 29 OECD countries (2005–2007) are tested.
  • Results show the tradeoff between energy use efficiency and economic development.
  • Difference of the initial CO2 emission from the optimal emission increase per year.



This article modifies the conventional two-stage DEA model to construct an analytical model for energy-related efficiency with undesirable outputs. Our proposed model relaxes the constraint that the inputs of the second process must come from the first process. As a result, our proposed model is more flexible than the original model in terms of the application of energy-related efficiency measurement analysis, and more policy implications may thus be provided by the decomposition of efficiencies for different processes. For demonstration purposes, the proposed model is applied to measure the energy use efficiency and the economic efficiency of 28 OECD countries during 2005 to 2007. The demonstration results reveal the following three findings. First, the average values of energy use efficiency are smaller than those of the average economic efficiency during the three-year period. It is shown that the OECD countries are only interested in economic development and are not concerned about energy use efficiency. Second, a tradeoff relationship exists between energy use efficiency and economic development for the OECD countries. Third, the differences of the initial carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from the optimal CO2 emissions as well as the average economic efficiency increase year by year. These results indicate that the OECD countries still discharge too much CO2. Finally, this article establishes a managerial decision-making matrix to divide 28 OECD countries into different positions according to their energy use and economic efficiencies, and provides improvement suggestions to policy makers.



Keywords: Two-stage data envelopment analysis; Carbon dioxide emissions; Energy-related efficiency; Undesirable output; Distance function.



Copyright © 2009-2014 AAQR All right reserved.